Amazing Stocking Stuffer Ideas from Orange Otter Toy Store!

Amazing Stocking Stuffer Ideas from Orange Otter Toy Store!

Amazing Stocking Stuffer Ideas from Orange Otter Toy Store!

No lumps of coal here! When it comes to Christmas, stockings are a beautiful tradition. We have curated a list of some of our favorite stocking stuffer ideas. We have plenty of games, toys and memory-making items to give your holiday that extra special touch.


Is there a more classic toy? It is an ancient toy with proof of existence since 500 BC! We have colorful wooden yo-yos in addition to the metal ones that are great for “walking the dog”!

Plus Plus

These awesome puzzles are TUBULAR! They each come with directions on how to build a character or kids can imagine and create their own. Great STEM challenge.

Tonie Characters

If you have gotten a Tonie box for your little one, grab one or two of their favorite characters for stocking stuffers! This will let them expand on the capabilities of their Tonie box and start to build a collection of friends. If you haven’t gotten a Tonie box yet, it is on Santa’s list for 2022!

Reese’s scented writing utensils

Markers, gel pens and notepads all with the delicious scent of the chocolate peanut butter treat we all know and love.

Crazy Aaron’s Thinking Putty

Choose from large or tiny tins. This putty doesn’t dry out and is addictive! It is a great stress reliever and way to channel energy.


The patented, award-winning Shashibo fidget box features 36 rare earth magnets for an innovative design that transforms into over 70 shapes. Fits comfortably in the hand (and stocking)! Enjoy hours of mind-challenging fun, stimulate the senses with unlimited creative possibility!

Sharkz, Unicornz and Slugz, OH MY!

Slugz are the latest (and possibly the greatest) new fidget toy! This articulated slug is better than normal slugs! It's satisfying to manipulate and makes a relaxing sound. Enjoy the original mini Slugz or the larger Sharkz and Unicornz!

World’s Smallest Series

The new line of miniature collectibles featuring the greatest toys of all time in the tiniest size! These are working miniatures. And if our tree in store doesn’t say it all, they make the PERFECT ornament or stocking stuffer. All your favorite toys and those you only dreamed of having can be found in miniature size. These tiny treasures fit into the palm of your hand!

Yoga Joes

Here to keep the inner peace. Green army men hold yoga poses instead of grenades! These hilarious collectibles will sure to make you smile. Don’t forget the accompanying comic book!

Mini Cars by Green Toys

Why do we love these great mini cars? Manufactured in the USA, made from 100% recycled plastic, no BPA, phthalates or PVC! Good for the environment, good enough for us!